Archive for August, 2009
Change in the South West Bank
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem, Southern Hebron Hills, West Bank on August 23rd, 2009
It is the end of August. Slow for news and burning hot in the West Bank. There are new signs of hope in the West Bank though. An organization has been set up that I feel is one of the most hopeful and positive signs for change in the West Bank. The organization is called Comet and consists of activists with a long record of activity in the South Mount Hebron region of the West Bank. They are dedicated and committed to the region’s communities by building renewable energy systems for communities that are not connected to the electricity grid because of political reasons and build local capacity to install and maintain those systems. The provision of renewable energy to off-grid communities answers a social, economic and environmental need. This is by no means a luxury issue but rather a matter of life-support in a particularly harsh situation. It is organizations like Comet that give me hope for the future of co-existence in this region.
Please have a look at their website and support the important work that they are doing in the South Hebron Hills. They have made it to the finals of the BBC’s World Challenge 2009 which means that they have a shot at winning a grant of 20,000$. It is very important that you get the word out about their work as it will help their chances in the World Challenge. You can visit their website, Twitter feed and Facebook page.
Zizek and Israeli Denial
Posted by Joseph Dana in Jerusalem on August 18th, 2009
Writing in today’s Guardian, Slavoj Zizek the rock star philosopher, makes the crucial point that,
“When peace-loving Israeli liberals present their conflict with Palestinians in neutral, symmetrical terms – admitting that there are extremists on both sides who reject peace – one should ask a simple question: what goes on in the Middle East when nothing is happening there at the direct politico-military level (ie, when there are no tensions, attacks or negotiations)? What goes on is the slow work of taking the land from the Palestinians on the West Bank: the gradual strangling of the Palestinian economy, the parcelling up of their land, the building of new settlements, the pressure on Palestinian farmers to make them abandon their land (which goes from crop-burning and religious desecration to targeted killings) – all this supported by a Kafkaesque network of legal regulations.”
This is it for me. I have been debating with many, both in the cyber world as well as in person, and often the response is that there are bad people on both sides. Another standard response is that we are both doing horrible things but we are not happy in doing these things, we are forced. Zizek’s article deconstructs this dangerous argument. The occupation does not stop. It has not stopped since 1967 and will not stop until…well, according to Zizek, there will be no possibility for a Palestinian state. Perhaps, but the issue is that it is no longer possible for Israelis to dismiss the occupation as the major problem in this conflict today. Don’t hold your breath because I do not see a sea change on the horizon.
Some links while I am recovering
Posted by Joseph Dana in Jerusalem on August 16th, 2009
I am still recovering my bout with the flu over the past days. While I recover fully have a look at some of these important links.
Helena Cobban on the recent Fatah conference.
Tony Karon on the peace process and outside influence.
The Human Rights Watch report on Gaza which has caused another bout of controversy in Israel this week.
Excellent article in Hebrew from Haaretz weekend about water issue in the West Bank.
Stephen Walt on Hussein Agha and Robert Malley’s Op-Ed in Tuesday’s New York Times
enjoy
Why is Israel so Dismissive?
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem on August 13th, 2009
The Israeli left is dead. It has been dead for years. With the recent offensive in Gaza and the election of a hard line right government, it looks as though it will not be coming back to life anytime soon. The settlements have not stopped growing and protests in Tel Aviv have not accomplished much. Things have gotten worse and people have gotten tired. They give up out of fatigue and frustration. People in certain circles on the right, on the other hand, have had no problem suffering through intense heat and cold while sitting on windswept hilltops throughout the West Bank in a demonstration of their political views and power. The mainstream left in Israel has lost that spirit a long time ago (perhaps it never had it to begin with) while the direct action left is trying to keep it alive but in small numbers.
Today’s Friday Edition of Haaretz has an Op-Ed piece written by Carlo Strenger, a Tel Aviv University professor entitled “Why Israel’s left has disappeared”. The article highlights what has become a commonplace argument against any and all criticism of Israeli polices in the West Bank and Gaza. Strenger writes,
“Israel’s policies since 1967 are evil stupidity or stupidly evil, and I continue to think that the occupation must end as quickly as possible. But I believe that Israel’s stupidity is matched by the Palestinians making every conceivable mistake along the way, and I think the left should give them the respect of holding them responsible for their actions rather than talking about them as if they were abused children”
Read the rest of this entry »
To Add Insult to Injury
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem on August 13th, 2009
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE TO ALL PRESS:
Evicted Palestinian families taken to court At 1500hrs (1400 GMT) today, the Hannoun and Ghawi families were served an order to appear in the District Court of Jerusalem at 1630hrs. The settlers that had moved into the Hannoun and Ghawi homes filed a restraining order for the Hannoun and Ghawi families to stay 150 metres from the homes.
The settlers had seized the houses an hour after more than 200 armed Israeli police invaded the houses and threw the Hannouns and Ghawis out into the streets on August 2, 2009. Since then, the families have been camped out on the sidewalk across their stolen homes, sleeping on mattresses, without causing any disturbances to the Jewish settlers.
They are still holding out hope that justice will be restored and the houses which they have always lived in will be restored to them.
h/t Ryan Linstrom
Sheikh Jarrah – In Memoriam
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem on August 10th, 2009
Last night in the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah there was a vigil, a memorial to the families’ homes from which they were evicted. First they were refugees and now they are homeless. After weeks of legal battles, sit-ins and press conferences, several hundreds gathered to acknowledge a critical defeat in the battle over the future of this land and the two peoples who want to live here in peace.
Yes, the Supreme Court ruled, yes, the Palestinians were evicted in accordance with the law and yes, the Jews who moved in there did so legally. But this is a matter of the future viability of a Palestinian state, and the true test, or more correctly, disclosure of Israel’s true intentions and integrity. Assuming the Jews who moved into these houses (and now pray on the rooftops looking down on the newly homeless families in the street), did in fact live there at some point, this only strengthens the argument that all Palestinian refugees are entitled to reclaim their lost homes all over Israel. Israel’s legal system has set this precedent. It has given legal credibility to the 7 million Palestinians who once lived somewhere in Israel and cannot return.
Israel could not be making it any clearer that its policy is to allow, encourage and facilitate Jewish settlement anywhere and everywhere it wishes, right in the middle of Palestinian communities, with the ultimate aim of clearing them out.
How can Israel, in its claim to represent the Jewish people, who have experienced the worst forms of discrimination, violence, ghettoization and homelessness, now inflict it on another people? And what exactly is it trying to achieve? Have we heard any Israeli politician actually articulate what the objective is here, other than showing off the country’s ability to kick people out and take over whatever place they want? What does Israel think it will gain from these reprehensible actions?
Settlers are looking for help breaking the law
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem, West Bank on August 9th, 2009
You have to love the audacity of the settlers to publicly announce their plans to break the law. Below is an ad from the Zionist Freedom Alliance looking for volunteers to “become pioneers and claim their stake in Jewish history” by breaking the law and building illegal outposts throughout the West Bank. Any takers?
the Zionist-dominated present
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem on August 8th, 2009
Powerful article by Lizzy Ratner on Mondoweiss.
“But far from freeing me to embrace Israel, this just made me more disturbed – more ragingly angry, frankly – by what Israel has done, and continues to do, to Palestinians. Again and again, as I stared at the remnants of ghetto walls, I wondered, baffled, how a people that was forced to live – and die – behind walls could force another people to live – and die – behind walls? Or how these same people who were pushed from their homes could push another people from their homes? Or force them to cross checkpoints, carry I.D., waste from hunger, dig tunnels to get food, and die at the blunt end of an Israeli missile? These are things I simply cannot understand. And as powerfully as I felt them before going to Poland, I feel them more powerfully now.”
“So in an attempt to re-wire the discourse just a bit, I would like to reclaim the Old Country from the jaws of Zionism. Instead of tours that whisk young people from Auschwitz to Israel, I would like to see trips that go from the Warsaw ghetto to the Jabaliya refugee camp. In place of a Jewish mainstream that looks only – and mistakenly – to Israel for its identity, I would like to see Jews who reach across time and space, to old countries and new countries, for a sense of who they are – and might be. But above all, if I can’t see an all-inclusive Yiddishe utopia resurrected in Poland, I would at least like to see the true lessons of “never again” enshrined in a single, consummately-inclusive Israeli-Palestinian state – a state that serves, through its unparalleled openness and respect for the rights of all its residents, as a true rebuke to the forces of hatred and genocide. I’ll admit that I don’t know exactly how to make it happen; policy often eludes me. But I do know that every reality begins with the notion of its possibility.”
Update from Sheikh Jarrah
Posted by Joseph Dana in Jerusalem on August 8th, 2009
Video of the scene yesterday in Sheikh Jarrah. Seeing the reporter stopped by the police reminds me of our experience in East Jerusalem recently. The police are sticking to their normal plan of action and only allowing settlers full freedom of movement.


Hände hoch oder ich filme
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem, West Bank on August 24th, 2009
At least some western media outlets are willing to cover co-existence between Israelis and Palestinians against the occupation. A German journalist recently joined a joint activity of Combatants for Peace and Ta’ayush near Tul Karem. Here is a link to the article that he filed in the German Paper Rheinicher Merkur for those that are able to read German.
“Auch wenn einige Teilnehmer Gitarren und Jonglierbälle mitgebracht haben, ist eine Eskalation fest eingeplant. Die Aktivisten erwarten wütende Siedler, ein hartes Durchgreifen der Armee, vielleicht sogar Festnahmen und Verletzte, wie es sie schon bei ähnlichen Aktionen gegeben hat. Das alles wollen sie mit Videos und Fotos dokumentieren – und wenn sie selbst dabei friedlich bleiben, glauben sie Moral und Sympathie auf ihrer Seite. „Es ist ein Krieg um die Bilder“, sagt Joseph Dana, ein erfahrener Aktivist, der regelmäßig über solche Ereignisse in seinem politischen Blog berichtet. „Es geht darum, zu zeigen, dass die Armee einseitig jüdische Siedler verteidigt.“
VON CHRISTOPH GUNKEL
coexistence, german, western media
3 Comments