Archive for November, 2009
Ta’ayush’s Own David Shulman on Goldstone
Posted by Joseph Dana in Jerusalem on November 17th, 2009
From the New York Review of Books blog:
Israel Without Illusions: What Goldstone Got Right
David Shulman

Detained Palestinians near an IDF post in Hebron, photographed by an Israeli soldier (Shovrim Shtika)
Questions of human rights abuses in Israel and the charges of war crimes put forward by the UN’s Goldstone report have produced little more than the usual disingenuous accusations of anti-Semitism. Even Moshe Halbertal, an unusually cogent Israeli participant-observer, takes the Goldstone commission to task in The New Republic for trying to link the Gaza campaign to the wider setting of the occupation and Israeli policies toward the Palestinians. “Why,” he asks, “should a committee with a mandate to inquire into the operation in Gaza deal with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict at large?”
There are, in my view, problems, distortions, and lacunae in the Goldstone report—some of them resulting from the fact that the Israeli government refused to cooperate with the UN commission. At the very least, Israeli testimony, both by ordinary soldiers and higher-ranking officers, might have modulated the sweeping conclusions in three of the most damning chapters of the report: “Chapter X. Indiscriminate Attacks by Israeli Armed Forces Resulting in the Loss of Life and Injury to Civilians”; “Chapter XI. Deliberate Attacks Against the Civilian Population”; and “Chapter XIII. Attacks on the Foundations of Civilian Life in Gaza.”
I also agree with Halbertal that Hamas benefits from an almost eerily neutral tone in the report.
But the report’s attempt to link whatever happened in Gaza with what has been going on in the West Bank for the last forty-two years is wholly justified. The political background to the report is, before all else, a cultural and moral one. I do not believe that a society can disenfranchise, dispossess, and effectively dehumanize large numbers of people living between Jenin and Hebron without this process influencing the way it conducts a war in Gaza. No one who regularly visits the Palestinian territories controlled by Israel has to speculate about whether or not Israel is engaged in the routine abuse of human rights.
Such abuse is the very stuff of the occupation—a daily reality exacerbated above all by the endless hunger for more land and the ever-expanding settlement project. That reality has been amply documented by Israeli human rights organizations such as B’Tselem and, more recently, Yesh Din (which offers legal aid to Palestinians), as well as by a large corpus of writings produced by firsthand witnesses, including those discussed in my 2007 book Dark Hope.
Read the rest of this entry »
Protest March from Zion Square to Sheikh Jarrah
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem on November 17th, 2009
צעדת מחאה שבועית מכיכר ציון לשייח ג’ראח
הצטרפו לצעדה ממערב ירושלים למזרח העיר, במחאה על העוולות הנעשות כנגד הציבור הפלסטיני במזרח ירושלים. הצעדה תסתיים בשייח ג’ראח בהפגנה כנגד מפעל ההתנחלות בשכונה.
הצעדה תצא מכיכר ציון בשעה 13:30 ביום שישי (20.11)
מדי שישי מתכנסים מתנחלים בשכונה להתפלל ולהפגין נוכחות. התקהלויות כאלה הובילו לא פעם לתקיפת המשפחות המפונות.
ביום שישי הקרוב יצטרפו אליהם חברים בארגון הימני הקיצוני “אם תרצו”
בואו לעורר מודעות ולמחות כנגד ההשתלטות של המתנחלים על מזרח ירושלים!
לפרטים או הרשמה להסעות מתל אביב: מאיה 054-7423044
Weekly Protest March from Zion Square to Sheikh Jarrah
Join a march from West to East Jerusalem in protest of the injustice committed against the Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem. The march will end in Sheikh Jarrah with a protest against the settler enterprise in the neighborhood.
The march will start at Zion Square at 13:30, Friday 20.11
Every Friday settlers gather in the neighborhood to pray and make their presence known. Such gatherings have often led to attacks on the evicted families.
This Friday they will be joined by members of the radical right wing movement “Im Tirtzu”
Come to raise awareness and protest the settlers’ attempt to take over East Jerusalem!
For further information or transportation from Tel Aviv: Maya 054-7423044
Raw Footage from Nil’in 13 Nov 2009
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, West Bank on November 17th, 2009
From Nil’in
Bil’in Habibti- Bil’in My Love
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, West Bank on November 17th, 2009
One of the best films to come out of the Israeli direct action left in a long time. If you have not seen this movie, then by all means go out and see it!
Palestinian Water Access in the South West Bank
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Southern Hebron Hills, West Bank on November 14th, 2009
Near the illegal outpost hilltop 18 just away from the uber settlement of Kiryat Arba is the Palestinian village of Al-Baqa. Israeli officials have begun cutting off water to the farmlands of this village in, yet another, bid to create difficulties for local residents in the hopes that they will leave the land for life in one of the major cities in the area. Al Jazeera has filed this report which includes some Ta’ayush footage.
Joseph the II, Jewish Emancipation and the Palestinians
Posted by Joseph Dana in Israel, Jerusalem on November 13th, 2009
What can the policy of Joseph II of the Hapsburg Empire towards the Jews teach us about the treatment of Palestinians in the West Bank by the Israeli government? On the surface, not to much but if we are to think theoretically, some important considerations arise from the policies of Joseph II.
Joseph II introduced a number of Toleranzpatent for the Jews living in his empire at the end of the 18th century. Perhaps the most famous and studied is the so called Edict of Tolerance issued to the Jews in 1780-82. The primary goal of this edict was to incorporate Jews into society for the benefit of the state. The primary vehicle for this transformation was education reform. Joseph II wanted the Jews to be included in German speaking schools and to be engaged in secular study. The idea was incorporation. At the time, this was revolutionary. But this document is only one in a series of important documents in the long and bumpy road of Jewish emancipation in Europe, which in my estimation ended in failure but that is a different post.
So what do the Palestinians have to do with this aspect of Jewish history? First, I am struck by the wording of the Edict especially if we change the names from Jews to Palestinians and Joseph II to Israel. Have a look and decide for yourself here. I have always thought that it would be a creative form of graffiti to post the Toleranzpatent throughout Jerusalem but with the terms changed.
Read the rest of this entry »
Zionist anti-Semitism from Haaretz
Posted by Joseph Dana in Jerusalem on November 13th, 2009
I have written on this website about the strange phenomenon of Zionist anti-Semitism. You can see previous posts here and here. In today’s Haaretz there is a disturbing article from Uzi Silber about this trend. Here is a link to another article by Silber.
“This is Jew Flu – the virus of Jewish Anti-Semitism, and its Jewish Anti- and Post-Zionist mutations, afflicting a small but inordinately loud minority of Hebrews. Its modern symptoms are a rejection of Israel’s identity as a Jewish state and a dismissal of its right to defend itself militarily, while embracing the goals of its nihilistic Arab enemies. Those infected with the virus wildly inflate Israeli sins real or imagined, while excusing or rationalizing Palestinian anti-semitism and outrages against Jews.
Those afflicted with Jew Flu often view the notion of Peoplehood as an artifice, which implies a rejection of Jewish national self-determination and acceptance of the 90-year-old Palestinian Arab contention that Jews are not a nation but merely members of a religion, and as such don?t merit a national home of their own.”


Gideon Levy remembers Amos Elon at NYU 18 Nov 2009
Posted by Joseph Dana in Jerusalem on November 23rd, 2009
Speaks for itself….
h/t Max Blumenthal
amos elon, Gideon Levy
1 Comment